S125v Vs S110v

S125v Vs S110vI'm sure s125v will be a bit more than orange if submerged in salt water as long as your vanax blade been. Then there are high-end alloys like ZDP-189, CPM S90V, CPM S110V, CPM S125V. CPM® S110V® and CPM® S125V® CPM S110V and CPM S125V provide the ultimate in wear and edge retention. Another aspect that helps is the use of Mo alloying which improves corrosion resistance for a given level of chromium, which is why S30V, S35VN, S125V, S110V, and S45VN have 2% or more Mo. The edge retention is likely a small step down from S35VN. The main differences between 20CV and S90V stainless are that the 20CV’s toughness is better than S90V, but edge retention, wear, and corrosion resistance are less than the S90V. Having said that, it is possible. S35VN, S110V, Niolox, and More. New article about S90V and S125V, including how they were developed, toughness and edge retention, and information on heat treating them. S90V Steel Vs 20CV 20CV, as the Crucible’s version of M390, is also premium steel with premium performance in knives. This is likely why no PM niobium steels have greater than 3. S110V is developed by Crucible and is a very popular steel type since it launched. According to Larrin's recent testing, they both do quite well in the CATRA test, though S110V did take the lead (718 vs. S110V is in short supply for custom makers. 5% V S90V has 9% V S110V has 9% V S125V has 12% V D david3151 Joined Apr 15, 2014 Messages 102 Jun 18, 2014 #7 Would. S125V is another notch below those other steels because of its greater volume of carbide. Looking at the charts you begin to see the big drop offs in toughness with the super high wear steels like S125 and above. S110V may be the best edge holding stainless steel. The toughness is probably a bit better than S35VN. Follow the heat treat recipe and the steel will harden. S110V Stainless Steel • Alpha Knife Supply. ru/Q6sfR Zero Tolerance - https://clck. The additional corrosion resistance while retaining all the benefits of S90V makes this steel extremely desired for kitchen cutlery. 5% V S90V has 9% V S110V has 9% V S125V has 12% V D david3151 Joined Apr 15, 2014 Messages 102 Jun 18, 2014 #7 Would M390 and S90V be the same as of sharping go's ? With S110V being the hardest to get a hair pooping edge. If the edge retention of S90V doesn’t cut it, S110V is superior. S90V Steel Review: Super Steel or Not?. All About CPM S45VN Knife Steel (Article)">All About CPM S45VN Knife Steel (Article). Bear in mind, despite having very high Chromium content - 20%, ZDP-189 is still susceptible to corrosion in humid. S110V has somewhat more carbide than S90V, making it even more impressive that the carbide size is finer. S30V has 4% V S60V has 5. S125V is another notch below those other steels because of its greater volume of carbide. However, this steel is not very popular. S110V also goes slightly higher in terms of corrosion resistance, toughness, and sharpenability. However, the S90V is also furnished with carbon and vanadium for wear. When custom makers like RJ Martin, Phil Wilson use it, and a company like Spyderco uses it in exclusive sprint runs, including it's own forum knife, you know it's one of the very best steels out there, provided it has the correct heat treat of HRC 62-63. S110V has slightly better edge retention and wear resistance, but S90V is tougher and more corrosion-resistant. My finding is similar to OP, S90V is easier to be touched up (following factory bevel) than S110V. According to Crucible Industries, "Crucible S125V has the highest attainable hardness of a CPM steel with a maximum attainable hardness of RC 65. Knife Myths: Premium Steels Are Always Better. My finding is similar to OP, S90V is easier to be touched up (following factory bevel) than S110V. Looking at the charts you begin to see the big drop offs in toughness with the super high wear steels like S125 and above. Typically harder steel will tend to be more brittle and prone to chipping. On paper, premium steels have better “stats” and “numbers” than budget steels, but in the real world, the vast majority of people aren’t going to be able to tell the difference between S110V and S30V. 5% Another important technical detail to note about CPM-125V is the manufacturing process that it undergoes. S110V is just one of those steels that needs to be experienced, it's just different going on my own personal experience with it over the years and in a wide hardness range, geometry and HT protocols. S125V – History and Properties. Also, while M398 only looks slightly lower than other high wear resistance stainless steels, the toughness differences are more significant at lower values. M390 = what steel , made in USA ? Last edited: Jun 18, 2014 I Invective Joined Jul 7, 2012 Messages. S110V has a finer carbide structure than either S90V or S125V. Chemical Composition Comparison. The S90V came first of course so it wasn’t designed as an improvement over S110V. 15V has corrosion resistance similar to M4, so it might turn into a tooth pick in concentrated salt water bath (in a year - hahaha). Just a few years ago, S30V was considered the best steel around. S125V, S110V">Corrosion resistance : (salt soak) VG. However, these differences are only minimal. S110V is stainless steel with about 15. 5 ft-lbs is roughly as significant as 10 vs 5 ft-lbs. This is likely why no PM niobium steels have greater than 3. In particular, S90V has similar toughness to many other PM stainless steels while also having significantly better edge retention. You can see the difference in the micrographs below. org/web/20110204132459/http://parrishknivesalaska. The carbide volume of S110V is closer to S125V which is significantly coarser. The carbide volume of S110V is closer to S125V which is significantly coarser. Then there are high-end alloys like ZDP-189, CPM S90V, CPM S110V, CPM S125V. Carbides in Maxamet – scienceofsharp">Carbides in Maxamet – scienceofsharp. S110V would win out but has to be heat treated for max corrosion resistance as a goal rather than hardness or wear resistance. S110V will have more abrasion resistance, real world use in my own experience over a variety of knives. S125V is used even less because of the difficulty in working with it. CPM S125V, online information is not available as of August 2014, contact Crucible Industries sales for information. S125V vs Rex 121. Both 20CV and S90V offer the same incredibly high edge retention. While it does not hold an edge as well as 1095, it is tough and easy to sharpen. S125V is closer to the hardness trendline extrapolated from S60V, so S125V appears to be slightly tougher when at equal hardness. This difference can be felt when whittling and cutting fibrous materials like cardboard and ropes despite the lack of change in heat treatment, the S45VN has a hardness rating of 61-62 compared to 59-60 of the S35VN. Crucible Steels for Knifemaking. The fine aluminum oxide erodes the iron matrix around the much harder carbides. CPM S110V steel is widely used in making industrial knives, screw elements, circular cutters, and food tools, to mention a few. I also believe S110V is tougher, but that could be. M398 Steel Testing – Edge Retention, Toughness, and More. There’s currently a race to the top when it comes to knife blade steels. S110V will cost a lot more per foot AND processing knife blades. CPM S110V has higher corrosion resistance than S90V and marginally better wear resistance. Steel Comparison Chart : r/knifeclub. Sharpening those steels (CPM S90V, CPM S110V, CPM S125V) to anything above 1000 grit creates a loss of performance and time. Future of Stainless Knife Steel Design?">What is the Future of Stainless Knife Steel Design?. S110V 2050°F (~27% carbide volume). Something like M390 doesn’t really have weaknesses, which to me is more important than something that has a couple strengths and a glaring weakness (like M4). S90V, S110V, and S125V appear to offer a superior combination of properties to the new M398. All About CPM S45VN Knife Steel (Article). Looking at the charts you begin to see the big drop offs in toughness with the super high wear steels like S125 and above. New Steel Bohler M398 – The New King of Edge …. Suggested Hardness: 56-59HRC, can go up to 61HRC S110V has much finer carbides. Shapton Glass 8k micro-bevelled Maxamet after moderate use. S110V is developed by Crucible and is a very popular steel type since it launched. S110V: The S30V has a great amount of toughness and is easy to sharpen compared to S110V. The main differences between 20CV and S90V stainless are that the 20CV’s toughness is better than S90V, but edge retention, wear, and corrosion resistance are less than the S90V. S110V=26 Maxamet=24 M390=26 So why should Maxamet be considered more premium than M390? While some steels might have incredible strengths, they may also have weaknesses. -, 视频播放量 2324、弹幕量 0、点赞数 21、投硬币枚数 2、收藏人数 4、转发人数 4, 视频作者鉴心作铁匠铺, 作者简介，相关视频：s125v它并没有刀圈说的那样脆弱不堪，热处理回火深冷才是关键，磨到薄的不能再薄我们带点小小刃角砍钢线测试就知道了，通体CPM-S125v粉末钢菜刀，碾压m390的存在. While folders are not quite in that hardness range, even at 63-64 HRC, ZDP-189 performs very well for push cutting. How Good Is S90V Steel? Get To Know In Details">How Good Is S90V Steel? Get To Know In Details. My finding is similar to OP, S90V is easier to be touched up (following factory bevel) than S110V. S90V, S110V, and S125V appear to offer a superior combination of properties to the new M398. Having said that, it is possible the factory edge is 'burnt' from power sharpening. -tempered high, S90V and S125V have the corrosion resistance lowered severely (25-30% of the low temper) -abrasive wear resistance of S90V (62 HRC) is very similar to BG-42 (63 HRC), 37 vs 41 -440C is significantly lower at 66 (58 HRC), and S125V much higher at 22 (64 HRC). Knifemaker Phil Wilson told us S110V holds an edge better than any stainless steel he ever tested. ru/Q6sdF Cultrotech Svarn - https://clck. Phil recommended it, I was very curious about it and decided to go for it. S110V has slightly better edge retention and wear resistance, but S90V is tougher and more corrosion-resistant. S125V is closer to the hardness trendline extrapolated from S60V, so S125V appears to be slightly tougher when at equal hardness. Vs S110v: Similarities & Differences. They both make great knife blades following proper heat treatment. If you want a blade that needs little attention and is difficult to make rust, but is also difficult to sharpen - go with the S110v. Scaling 20CV VS S90V Stainless Steel. Also, the history of these steels in knives, how knifemakers perceived the steel early on, and why they aren’t mainstream knife steel choices. The first one which is known as P atent was launched in 2006 and the latter was launched in 2010 and is known as F inal. CAUTION: These grades are only appropriate for knifemakers with substantial experience in difficult-to-grind materials! CPM® S30V® CPM S30V was designed for cutlery and offers the best overall combination of hardness, corrosion resistance. Because of the low toughness, tools, and knives made from CPM 15V easily fracture and break when exposed to high impact. s90v vs s110v, why do we have both? : r/knifeclub. S110V has a finer microstructure and better corrosion resistance but more carbide. If the edge retention of S90V doesn’t cut it, S110V is superior. S110V may be the best edge holding stainless steel. S110V steel beats S125V knife steel in toughness due to the slightly low hardness. com/&source=gmail&ust=1487109711458000&usg=AFQjCNHbHPTciGYsJdUELu7p47bOjvq1-w. Knife Myths: Premium Steels Are Always Better. CPM S125V is exceptionally difficult to grind and process, plus the batch he was working with had some defective bars too, then on top of all that CPM S125V got discontinued. One way around this issue is to produce the powder steel without carbon first so that niobium carbides are not formed. Once the very sharp edge fizzles out on all three steels then the S110V is going to keep that "sort of good enough" edge very significantly longer. ZDP-189 can go up to 67-68 HRC. S110V=26 Maxamet=24 M390=26 So why should Maxamet be considered more premium than M390? While some steels might have incredible strengths, they may also have weaknesses. According to Crucible Industries, "Crucible S125V has the highest attainable hardness of a CPM steel with a maximum attainable hardness of RC 65. The steel must be heat treated to get to a hardened state. S90v Vs S110v: Similarities & Differences. Hey Sal, any chance of a Vanax SC mule??. As the patent [18] says, “It has. The Spyderco S110V Manix 2 G10 is about $140, a heavier duty type knife with a 4 way pocket clip and Ball Bearing Lock. (Yes, I know you’re the exception!) The same thing goes for locking mechanisms. Top SpyderNut Member Posts: 8422 Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 4:33 pm. It tolerates less than ideal temperature control in forging and heat-treating (As does 5160). The S90V came first of course so it wasn’t designed as an improvement over S110V. S110V has almost 9% Vanadium, which is probably why it's such a pain to sharpen. Corrosion resistance : (salt soak) VG-10, S125V, S110V - YouTube 0:00 / 9:30 Corrosion resistance : (salt soak) VG-10, S125V, S110V Cliff Stamp 8. S110V is certainly not my first choice. Suggested Hardness: 56-59HRC, can go up to 61HRC S110V has much finer carbides which lends to being better at holding a fine polished edge. 10V is in the D2 range or better for toughness depending on which chart you are looking at. com">K390 Versus S110V Mule. 25% Cr for improved corrosion resistance. Phil is a great knifemaker and master heat treater. (To be clear, S30V is just as great as. While both are stainless steel, S110V steel will offer better corrosion resistance than S125V. It's common to hear S90V as CPM S90V, referring to Crucible Particle Metallurgy. This totally surprised me and I think this is due to the smaller size of carbide in the S110v than in the S90v. CPM® S110V® Click Here: CPM® S125V® Click Here: CPM® S30V® Click Here: CPM® S35VN™ Click Here: CPM® S45VN™ Click Here: CPM® S60V® Click Here: CPM® S90V® Click Here CPM® Tool Steel: CPM® 10V® Click Here: CPM® 15V® Click Here: CPM® 1V® Click Here: CPM® 3V® Click Here: CPM® 4V® Click Here: CPM® 9V® Click Here: CPM. S110V has a finer carbide structure than either S90V or S125V. Super steel comparison? (K294, Rex121, 10V, etc). Both used smoothed out DMT EEF. History, Properties, and How to Heat Treat. S110V has a finer carbide structure than either S90V or S125V. The main advantage of this particular type of steel for knives is its durability and wear resistance. ZDP-189 is quite a bit harder, which is probably the largest contributing factor to its wear resistance. S125V Stainless Steel Information and Composition Condition: This alloy been properly annealed and is in the soft condition. Flat Ground: Any alloy that has “Flat Ground” in the description has been Blanchard ground. On a scale of 1 to 10, 15V knife steel has a toughness of 3, which is very low and comparable to other low toughness steels like S110V. Corrosion resistance : (salt soak) VG-10, S125V, S110V - YouTube 0:00 / 9:30 Corrosion resistance : (salt soak) VG-10, S125V, S110V Cliff Stamp 8. The addition of niobium also helps with corrosion resistance. What is the Future of Stainless Knife Steel Design?. S110V steel beats S125V knife steel in toughness due to the slightly low hardness. The lower chromium content of those steels means they have more vanadium carbide rather than chromium carbide, so they are expected to have similar edge retention with lower carbide volume. Looking at the charts you begin to see the big drop offs in toughness with the super high wear steels like S125 and above. ru/Q6sgS Zero Tolerance 0640 - https://clck. The blade was then used for various cutting tasks and imaged at three stages; after light, moderate and heavy use. [citation needed]While a common material for swords or hatchets, it is less than ideal for most knives because of its limited attainable hardness. CPM S125V - 3. CAUTION: These grades are only appropriate for knifemakers with substantial experience in difficult-to-grind materials! CPM® S30V® CPM S30V was designed for cutlery and offers the best overall combination of hardness, corrosion. It cuts more aggressively and is not a stainless steel. You do not have to do any non-standard wasteful processes before heat treating. And s110v is anything but "cheap" in any sense of the word. Phil Wilson CPM S110V Meadows Skinner Custom Knife Review. Rex 121 vs S110V. S110V is stainless steel with about 15. However, the S90V is also furnished with carbon and vanadium for wear resistance. You can see the difference in the micrographs below. And as awesome as s110v is (regarding what it excels at), performance wise, maxamet is (arguably) generally better. S110V corrosion resistance is among the best in knife steel; it is on par with M390 steel, CTS 204P steel, and 20CV. The S110v comes with decent Edge retention but surprisingly underperforms when compared to the S90v. Typically harder steel will tend to be more brittle and prone to chipping. Its chemical composition makes it highly wear/corrosion resistant, tough, and ductile. The unique manufacturing process also allows for a more durable knife material, since weak areas caused. And at this time CPM S110V was introduced. S110V corrosion resistance is among the best in knife steel; it is on par with M390 steel, CTS 204P steel, and 20CV. Corrosion resistance : (salt soak) VG-10, S125V, S110V - YouTube 0:00 / 9:30 Corrosion resistance : (salt soak) VG-10, S125V, S110V Cliff Stamp 8. S90V and S110V are both a higher tier for toughness than M398. S90V has a bit better toughness and inexplicably it has better edge retention in CATRA testing. For me M390 and M4 just work better for me because they guarantee a VERY sharp edge for a longer period. Another aspect that helps is the use of Mo alloying which improves corrosion resistance for a given level of chromium, which is why S30V, S35VN, S125V, S110V, and S45VN have 2% or more Mo. Maxamet is the new hotness with a fun name. Both the steel blades are easier to sharpen and take almost the same time in sharpening. Corrosion resistance : (salt soak) VG. The overall difference in terms of ft-lbs is relatively small, but differences are more significant at low values. CPM® S110V® and CPM® S125V® CPM S110V and CPM S125V provide the ultimate in wear and edge retention. CPM S110V steel is widely used in making industrial knives, screw elements, circular cutters, and food tools, to mention a few. Spyderco Military S110V Review. Its two versions have been launched. On paper, premium steels have better “stats” and “numbers” than budget steels, but in the real world, the vast majority of people aren’t going to be able to tell the difference between S110V and S30V. Sometimes it requires several sharpening sessions to get to good steel. 3% CARBON, 14% CR, 12% VANADIUM, MOLY 2. Another very popular model that will give the same performance in a smaller package. This difference can be felt when whittling and cutting fibrous materials like cardboard and ropes despite the lack of change in heat treatment, the S45VN has a hardness rating of 61-62 compared to 59-60 of the S35VN. Edge Retention, Toughness, and More. S110V is essentially a modified version of S90V or S125V designed for improved corrosion resistance when compared with those steels. S90V and S125V – History and Properties. The overall difference in terms of ft-lbs is. And as awesome as s110v is (regarding what it excels at), performance. On a scale of 1 to 10, 15V knife steel has a toughness of 3, which is very low and comparable to other low toughness steels like S110V. S90V and S125V Knife Steel. CPM S125V Stainless Steel • Alpha Knife Supply. CPM® S110V® and CPM® S125V® CPM S110V and CPM S125V provide the ultimate in wear and edge retention. S110V is stainless steel with about 15. S110V will have more abrasion resistance, real world use in my own experience over a variety of knives. S110V is supposed to have much better corrosion resistance, and from the looks of it much better edge holding. CPM S110V has higher corrosion resistance than S90V and marginally better wear resistance. CPM S110V steel is widely used in making industrial knives, screw elements, circular cutters, and food tools, to mention a few. The resulting steel is expected to have similar hardness and corrosion resistance to S30V and S35VN. I also believe S110V is tougher, but that could be subjective. 5% V S90V has 9% V S110V has 9% V S125V has 12% V D david3151 Joined Apr 15, 2014 Messages 102 Jun 18, 2014 #7 Would M390 and S90V be the same as of sharping go's ? With S110V being the hardest to get a hair pooping edge. The carbide volume of S110V is closer to S125V which is significantly coarser. S90V and S110V are almost identical steel with similar properties that don't exhibit many differences. S90V works better with a coarse, toothy edge due to having relatively large carbides. We greatly respect him and his opinion. S110V is a unique steel, much different than simply the middle sibling between s90v and s125v. This is what I want, need and enjoy. However, this steel is not very popular in the knife-making industry because it is hard to work with just like its upgraded counterpart CPM S125V Steel. A CATRA testing by Larrin Thomas shows S90V steel is second only to the much harder alternative S125V – also manufactured by Crucible. S110V is a unique steel, much different than simply the middle sibling between s90v and s125v. And sharpening is probably a bit easier to S35VN. S125V is used even less because of the difficulty in working with it. A CATRA testing by Larrin Thomas shows S90V steel is second only to the much harder alternative S125V - also manufactured by Crucible. S90V has 14% Cr and 1% Mo, while S110V has 2. S35VN has superior corrosion resistance to S90V despite both having 14% Cr in part because S35VN has higher Mo. Super steel comparison? (K294, Rex121, 10V, etc)">Super steel comparison? (K294, Rex121, 10V, etc). S90V: In the series of steel created by Crucible, S90V is a high-end one which is more difficult to sharpen compared to S30V. S110V is in short supply for custom. Suggested Hardness: 56-59HRC, can go up to 61HRC S110V has much finer carbides which lends to being better at holding a fine polished edge. This also means that there will be longer periods between sharpening times. Today, S30V is sometimes considered an ancient steel while newer steels like S110V are praised for being even better. And s110v is anything but "cheap" in any sense of the word. S110V has somewhat more carbide than S90V, making it even more impressive that the carbide size is finer. S110v is virtually perfect with great corrosion resistance and holds a working edge forever. The 20CV is introduced with the most extensive chromium and vanadium carbide range. The fine aluminum oxide erodes the iron matrix around the much harder carbides. Carbides in Maxamet – scienceofsharp. CPM S30V Steel: Is it a Good Knife Steel?. 25% chromium elements, offers better corrosion resistance than non-stainless Rex 121 at about 4. Availability will depend on runs, schedules etc. Again there is some out there but until Crucible/Niagra makes more available it is not going to be in common use. I've done it more than once, alternating between 700-800 grit and 100K edges, and for aggressiveness and durability coarse edges on those steels are very hard to match. This will be relevant to the toughness discussion later on. Its chemical composition makes it highly wear/corrosion resistant, tough, and. Shapton Glass 8k micro-bevelled Maxamet after light use. S90V and S110V are both a. S110V would win out but has to be heat treated for max corrosion resistance as a goal rather than hardness or wear resistance. Yet, S90V beats S30V in terms of resisting corrosion and toughness level. S125V is closer to the hardness trendline extrapolated from S60V, so S125V appears to be slightly tougher when at equal hardness. ago Cool, did not know that either, thanks!. S110V has somewhat more carbide than S90V, making it even more impressive that the carbide size is finer. Knife Myths: Premium Steels Are Always Better. Rex 121 and S110V steel offer high Rockwell hardness, Rex 121 though offers more at about 71 HRc while S110V at about 66 HRc. While both are stainless steel, S110V steel will offer better corrosion resistance than S125V. It's about as wear resistant as I'd go other than as an experiment. Spyderco seems to do a good job with it in their Manix 2, it's at 62 RC and worked fine for me at the stock. New article about S90V and S125V, including how they were developed, toughness and edge retention, and information on heat treating them. S110V steel beats S125V knife steel in toughness due to the slightly low hardness. S110V has slightly better edge retention and wear resistance, but S90V is tougher and more corrosion-resistant. [citation needed]While a common material for swords or hatchets, it is less than ideal for most knives because of its limited attainable hardness. Hopefully we will be able to learn more as knives are released. Having said that, it is possible the factory edge is ‘burnt’ from power sharpening. 10V is in the D2 range or better for toughness depending on which chart you are looking at. Suggested Hardness: 59-61HRC, can go up to 64HRC Kboehm • 6 yr.